I=
Pakistan Research Repository Home
 

Title of Thesis

An Analysis of Paradigm Shift from Public Extension to Public Private Partnership Extension System in NWFP, Pakistan

Author(s)
Ikram Ul Haq
Institute/University/Department Details

Department of Agricultural Extension / University of Agriculture Faisalabad

Session
2009
Subject
Agricultural Extension
Number of Pages
262
Keywords (Extracted from title, table of contents and abstract of thesis)
Paradigm Shift,Public Extension, Public Private Partnership Extension System, NWFP

Abstract
A general weakness of agricultural extension is the low adoption of new agricultural technologies by poor and small farmers. As the present public extension systems in many countries have not been able to address the issues and concerns of small and poor farmers, a search for new extension models that are more effective, efficient, and responsive to different categories of farmers is essential. This essential model might be the public-private partnership. Govt. of NWFP has initiated a new public private partnership extension program in the province during the year 2000. This emerging system is locally called as Farm Services Centers (FSCs) where inputs delivery, market facilitation, exchange of experiences and knowledge are the main activities of the system. However, there is still information gap about whether this public-private partnership will be beneficial in developing and extending agricultural technologies. This study intends to fill up that information gap by analyzing this public-private partnership by measuring its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. For this purpose, out of 24 districts, two districts Swabi and Lakki Marwat were selected randomly as study area from where 217 and 274 farmer respondents were selected at random with the help of table given by Fitzggibbon et al. (1987), making a total of 491 respondents. All the Agricultural officers and district officers of the selected districts were also selected as respondents of the study. Quantitative data were colleted by survey method, while qualitative data by focus group discussion with the help of open-ended interview schedule. The results showed that the most important strength of FSC in the eyes of farmer respondents was “managed by farmers’ bodies” as ranked 1st with mean 4.05 and SD 1.29. The weaknesses of both extension systems as diagnosed by the farmer respondents were “no sale arrangements for surplus produce”. In case of opportunities, FSC was bottom up approach and “based on partnership between farmers and the government” ranked 1st with mean 4.12 and SD 1.29. The threats for FSC as reported by farmers respondents were “no trend to develop farmers’ organizations among farming community”, “pressure exerted by political influential authorities” and “low preference of agriculture by youth as full time occupation”. According to EFS respondents the most important strength for FSC was “managed by farmers’ bodies” which ranked 1st with means 4.82 and SD 0.40. The major weaknesses of FSC as diagnosed by EFS respondents were “no female staff”, “no sale arrangements for surplus produce”, and “lack of marketing facilities” ranked 1st, 2nd, and 3rd .The statements “offers low cost of learning”, “based on partnership between farmers and the government”, “provides forum for farmers to get together”, “proved extension workers to be good change agents”, and “encourages farmers participation” were the top five opportunities of the system. Out of all threats, EFS ranked the statement “no trend to develop farmers’ organizations among farming community” as 1st threat with mean 3.82 and SD 1.40. On the basis of conclusions it was recommended that Government should provide the opportunities of availing projects of different funding agencies to increase the share of private sector on FSC basis. Government should formulate law to increase the participation of women in the present programs, as they are main component of agriculture. Department should provide more facilities like pay and other allowances to the staff indulged in FSC to increase their working efficiency. As recommended by respondents separate meeting places should be provided for female farmers, so as they effectively get trainings and efficiently utilized the acquired knowledge in relevant fields.

Download Full Thesis
7432.5 KB
S. No. Chapter Title of the Chapters Page Size (KB)
1 0 CONTENTS 8
186 KB
2 1 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Agricultural Extension

1.2 Agricultural Extension Programmes of Pakistan

1.3 Agricultural Extension in NWFP, Past and Present

1.4 Public Extension Services in Pakistan

1.5 Paradigm Shift

1.6 Partnership

1.7 Public-Private Partnership

1.8 Farm Services Centers (FSCs)

1.9 Need for the Study

1.10 Objectives

1.11 Limitations

1.12 Assumptions

16
190 KB
3 2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE

2.1 Bibliographical information

2.2 Public Extension in the World

2.3 Public and Private sector Extension

2.4 Constraints of Public Sector Extension

2.5 Criticism on Public Sector Extension

2.6 Private extension in the world

2.7 Private extension in Asia

2.8 Private extension in Pakistan

2.9 Approaches used in Agricultural Extension

2.10 Public-Private Partnership in Extension

2.11 Synthesis of Review of Literature

61
281 KB
4 3 MATERIALS AND METHODS

3.1 Pakistan: The country of study

3.2 NWFP: Universe of the study

3.2 The selection of study area

3.4 Sampling procedure and sampling size

3.5 Selection of sample

3.6 Preparation of Interview schedule

3.7 Reliability

3.8 Validity

3.9 Translation

3.10 Data Collection

3.11 Analysis of data

3.12 Focus Group Discussion

3.13 Problems faced during data collection

16
390 KB
5 4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

4.1 Farmer respondents

4.2 Extension field staff respondents

4.3 Focus group discussion

4.4 SWOT Matrix

92
2068 KB
6 5  SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

5.1 Summary

5.2 Conclusions

5.3 Recommendations

5.4 Strategy for an improved extension model

14
131 KB
7 6 LITERATURE CITED 31
829 KB
  6.1 APPENDICES 17